Band Saw vs Scroll Saw: Which is Better One?


As a crafter and a DIYer, there will come a moment for you to face a project where you need a fresh saw. The issue is, there are so many out there, and when it comes to scroll saw vs band saw, you may be confused which is best adapted to your requirements. You will need to understand the variations in scroll vs. band saw to create that choice, what each can do, and which is the best instrument for your particular assignment.

What is a Scroll Saw?

The scroll saw has a tiny, narrow, vertically mounted blade of the saw, anchored at the top and bottom, moving up and down to cut your wood. The engine establishes a velocity, or you can use a foot pedal to control the blade. You can push your wood on the surface of the job once it’s on, cutting into any pattern or design you choose.

What is the best thing about Scroll Saw?

For creating small and super-detailed cuts, this saw is outstanding: dollhouse furniture, decorations, puzzles, and inlays. A paper model can be attached to the wood and carved along the lines or freehand drawings can be installed. Its tiny blades, including correct angles and S shapes, allow you to get into very narrow corners. You can even tilt the blade to create angled cuts while maintaining the table surface flat.

You can generate very accurate cuts because you can use two hands, and they will be so smooth that you will need to do little or no sanding afterward. Scroll saws are quiet and don’t produce much dust, plus changing the blades is a snap, making it user-friendly. They’re secure enough to work for kids. With an accessible near-instant gratification level combined with the capacity to use a pattern, scroll saws are one of the best ways to introduce children to woodworking.

However, what really distinguishes the scroll saw is “pierce cuts.” You can lift the blade, slide the wood under it, push through the blade, and reassemble the blade below. The blade is now trapped inside the wood and can cut designs that have been hollowed out. You detach and lift the blade out of the project when you’ve completed the interior cuts.

What is a Band Saw?

Usually, a band saw is bigger than a scroll saw. It generally comprises of two vertically focused big wheels on which rotates a flexible metal cutting blade, like a bicycle chain or an old-school film projector. The engine turns the wheels and the blade rotates quickly as well. These blades come in a multitude of sizes and kinds to suit the job (which can even include metal cutting). You can push the wood on and off the blade with two fingers, either in a straight row or in corners or in curves.

What is the best thing about Band Saw?

A band saw will cut clean, soft curves into even the thickest of lumber, unlike your table saw or even your circular saw. You can cut a perfect circle or irregular waves and each time you get a smooth surface. As with a scroll saw, you can’t make super tight turns, but you can use thick wood that won’t accommodate a scroll saw. Band saws are popular with furniture manufacturers as you can readily use one to create tables and chairs with curved legs.

Lovers of band saws like to use it instead of a table saw to tear boards more securely, and the band saw is usually quicker, particularly when working with big parts. Although with a maximum cutting height of 12 “most woodworkers are pleased enough, you can get machines for your store that handle twice that size of wood. You can resaw boards into lower thicknesses if you want to give your planer a day off (such as cutting cheese from a block).

And some like a band saw that it rips and resaws panels with a power tool’s velocity and accuracy, but leaves behind the personality in the grain you generally see only when using hand saws. You could resaw a board into two parts, for instance, and use the inside faces as two gates on a cabinet to highlight the continuity of the grain across the whole front of the piece.

When to Use Scroll Saw?

If you work with tiny, thin fabrics and do crafts or ornamental work mainly, a scroll saw is the best choice when using a scroll saw. The slender, brief blade allows very smooth and accurate complex, thorough cuts. Plus, you can do indoor plunge cuts with a scroll saw unlike a band saw.

band saw

When to Use Band Saw?

If your projects need a lot of energy, the best way to go is to see a group. The constant blade is intended to cut up to 2 inches thick parts of the material. In reality, the only restriction to how dense this machine can cut with the correct blade is how much space there is between the job surface and the top of the machine. One thing that band saws are particularly efficient at is making aggressive straight cuts quickly and accurately.

One reason for this is that the blade always runs in the same direction, eliminating even the slightest motion of the material up and down while you are working. You can also create arches, circles and other forms with a band saw with the correct blades and jigs, but maintain in mind that they can only cut outside.

A band saw can also cut through materials that a scroll saw couldn’t address, even metal, with the correct blade. All this doesn’t mean that with a band saw you can’t get creative and crafty–you can. You’re just not going to be able to get the same nice information and complex cut-outs you can with a scroll saw.

Scroll Saw

What’s the Scroll Saw vs Band Saw difference?

You’ll want to think about the purpose of each instrument when you’re confronted with the decision between a group vs. scroll saw. Here are the primary differences between these instruments:


A scroll saw is perfect for making a complex project layout. These sensitive saws use an oscillating movement and can provide a smooth, professional finish. On the other side, the band saw is designed to cut dense materials through and is often discovered in an industrial or professional environment.


The size of the material you plan to cut will play a major part in which you have seen your use. A scroll saw utilizes slender, sensitive blades (1/4 inches thick and 8 inches long) which are not appropriate for cutting through dense bits of wood A band saw can operate up to 30 inches with material between 6 inches.


A scroll saw will be the ideal option if you need to make curves or circular cuts or even detailed cuts because, thanks to the fixed saw, you can move the material around as you need. Usually, a band saw is preferred when making a straight cut. If you’re trying to make designs with these saws, they won’t be as complex or accurate as you would like them to be.


A scroll saw will provide more versatility, as a broad variety of cuts can be made. Usually, a band saw is best suited for periodic cutting.


Naturally, power tools will cost a good quantity of cash, and when you try to decide between a scroll saw vs. band saw, it will be something you will need to consider. A scroll saw will generally be the cheaper alternative, as it is often used by craftsmen and DIYers. A band saw is more costly because it is more commercial and the skilled woodworkers often prefer it.


A scroll saw vs band saw looked very similar. You might actually believe that they can be used for the same project kinds. There’s a little overlap, but for two very distinct reasons, these saws are truly created. A scroll saw should be your go-to piece of machinery if you make ornamental, comprehensive cuts with lots of curved edges and cuts inside into a thin piece of wood. For employment that requires a lot of accuracies, the fine, flexible blade was produced.

You can’t go wrong with a band saw for thicker material and more aggressive employment, including rip cutting. They are strong, aggressive, and good to make straight cuts. If you do enough woodworking or a broad variety of projects, you would definitely be justified in getting a scroll saw in your workshop as well as a band saw. They are vastly distinct instruments used for very distinct reasons. You’re certainly going to discover a way to use both.

You May Also Read: How To Use A Band Saw Safely?


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.